Gold Coins
American Eagles, Krugerrands, Canadian Maple Leafs, pre-1933 U.S. gold, and foreign gold. Paid on melt plus numismatic premiums for scarce dates.
New York City · All Five Boroughs
NYC Coin Buyers: Sell Gold, Silver & Rare Coins in New York City
Trusted local buyers of gold coins, silver coins, rare and certified coins, bullion, and full collections. Straight, no-pressure offers based on today’s market.
Call for a free appraisal
347-650-4078- Cash or wire
- By appointment
- Discreet
- Same-day offers
Request a quote
Get a free offer on your collection.
Send a few details and a buyer will call you back the same day with a no-obligation offer.
Cash paid on the spot
No waiting periods, no mail-in delays, no follow-up calls.
By appointment
Schedule a time and we evaluate your coins while you wait.
Discreet & private
No public displays. Transactions handled professionally.
All five boroughs
Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island & Long Island.
Local · In-person · Same day
Coin Buyers Near You Across New York City
Searching for a trusted coin buyer near you? NYC Coin Buyers is the local buyer serving sellers across all five boroughs from a downtown Manhattan office: Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, and out to Long Island. Bring in gold coins, silver coins, rare and graded coins, bullion, or a full estate collection for an in-person appraisal and a same-day cash offer.
Every offer is benchmarked to
- PCGS Price Guide
- CDN Greysheet
- Live COMEX spot
- Heritage Auctions
- Stack’s Bowers
What we buy
Sell Gold in NYC: Coins, Bullion & Jewelry
NYC Coin Buyers purchases a wide range of numismatic and bullion material from private sellers across New York City. Whether you have a single gold coin, a bag of pre-1964 silver, a complete Morgan dollar set, or a full estate collection, our buyers evaluate everything with care. We pay based on current metal spot prices and reference published numismatic guides for collector coins. No hidden fees and no consignment delays. We make an offer and pay on the spot.
Silver Coins
Morgan and Peace dollars, pre-1964 90% silver, Silver Eagles, Walking Liberty halves, Mercury dimes. Individual coins, rolls, or full bags.
Rare & Certified Coins
PCGS and NGC graded coins, key dates, mint errors, proof sets, and early American coinage. We reference current market data for every offer.
Bullion Bars
Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium bars in any size. We buy PAMP Suisse, Credit Suisse, Engelhard, Johnson Matthey, and Perth Mint.
Currency & Paper Money
Old U.S. currency, large-size notes, fractional currency, gold and silver certificates. Bring what you have for an honest evaluation.
Jewelry & Scrap Gold
Rings, necklaces, bracelets, broken pieces, dental gold, and scrap. We test every item for purity in front of you: 10K, 14K, 18K, and 24K.
How it works
How Selling Your Coins in NYC Works
01
Call to schedule
Call 347-650-4078 to set an appointment. We discuss what you have and confirm a time. Buyers available Monday through Saturday.
02
We appraise while you wait
Our buyers examine your coins on the spot. Expect 30 to 60 minutes for large collections. A handful of coins typically takes ten. Every piece gets attention.
03
You get a written offer
We give you an itemized, written offer that breaks down what we pay for each group. Accept, decline, or take it to another buyer. No obligation.
04
Cash or wire same day
Accept the offer and leave with cash (up to our daily limit) or have funds wired to your bank the same business day.
Have questions? Call us.
347-650-4078The math behind the offer
What Determines the Offer You Receive for Your Coins
Every offer we make is grounded in publicly available market data. We explain what drives each number so you can verify it independently.
Metal Content
For bullion coins and common gold or silver, the metal spot price drives the offer. New York sellers typically get closer to spot on larger quantities and clean, recognizable bullion.
Numismatic Value
Rare coins, key dates, and high-grade certified coins sell for well above melt. Our buyers reference the PCGS Price Guide, the Greysheet, and recent auction records.
Condition & Certification
Coins graded by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS command premiums. Raw coins are priced conservatively because authentication risk falls on the buyer, so bring graded coins in their holders.
Melt vs numismatic
A 1921 Morgan silver dollar contains about $20 of silver at today’s spot. In uncirculated condition it can bring several times that. A 1921-D Morgan carries the same silver content but can sell for far more because of its rarity. Knowing what you have before you sell keeps real money in your pocket, which is why we always provide itemized, written offers.
Service area
Serving All Five Boroughs and Long Island
NYC Coin Buyers welcomes sellers from across New York City and the surrounding area. Sellers regularly come in from Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, Staten Island, and neighborhoods throughout Manhattan, along with the towns just out on Long Island.
Many New Yorkers come to us after receiving a quote from an online buyer. They want a direct, in-person appraisal from someone who can examine the coins. Remote estimates miss details that matter, and we regularly find value that mail-in services overlook.
For large collections or situations where transport is difficult, ask about our at-home appraisal option anywhere in the five boroughs. Our buyers can come to you when the collection warrants it.
View full service area → ManhattanBrooklynQueensThe BronxStaten IslandAstoriaLong Island CityFlushingWilliamsburgPark SlopeForest HillsRiverdaleHarlemLong Island
Why local
Why Sell Coins Locally Instead of Online
No shipping risk.
Online buyers require you to mail high-value items, often with insurance ceilings below what you’re sending. Bring coins in person and they never leave your hands until you accept an offer.
No delay between appraisal and payment.
Mail-in buyers receive your coins, examine them, and send an offer you may not agree with. Getting coins back after declining means waiting again. In person, you get the offer while you wait.
We see every coin in context.
Photos miss critical details: subtle toning, luster breaks that affect grade, hairlines from past cleaning, and die varieties that can multiply value. We examine coins under proper lighting with loupes.
You can walk away at any point.
Shipping coins to an online buyer commits you to a process that is hard to reverse. In person means zero commitment until you sign off. Decline the offer, take the paperwork, and use it to get other bids.
Vs pawn shops
Why New Yorkers Come to Us Instead of Pawn Shops
Most pawn shops buy gold at a steep discount to melt because they need to flip it fast and cover overhead. NYC Coin Buyers connects directly to a network of collectors, investors, and auction houses. That’s why we can pay more.
We show our math.
You see the spot price, the coin’s grade, and the demand. If you want to shop our offer around, go ahead. We’ll even show you how to check gold and silver value yourself.
No pressure, no pitch.
We’re coin people, not salespeople. Come in, get your appraisal, and decide on your own time.
We handle estate collections.
Inherited coins and don’t know what you have? That’s exactly what we do. We catalog everything and give you values, piece by piece.
Same-day payment.
Cash or wire when you accept. No waiting, no runaround, no consignment delays.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions About Selling Coins in NYC
Where can I sell my coins in NYC?
NYC Coin Buyers is a dedicated coin and bullion buyer serving all five boroughs from a downtown Manhattan office. We’re professional numismatists, not a pawn shop or a jewelry store buying coins on the side. We evaluate every piece based on current market data. Appointments are preferred for collections. Call 347-650-4078 to schedule.
How much do coin buyers in New York pay for silver coins?
Common pre-1964 90% silver coins are paid primarily on their silver content against the live spot price, typically a strong percentage of melt depending on quantity and coin type. Better-date and higher-grade silver coins carry a numismatic premium above melt. We show you exactly how each figure is built.
Should I clean my coins before selling them?
No, please don’t. Cleaning almost always reduces a coin’s value, sometimes dramatically, because it damages the original surface collectors pay for. Bring coins exactly as they are and let us evaluate them in their current state.
How do I know if my coins are valuable?
Value comes down to metal content, date and mint mark, condition, and rarity. You don’t need to know any of this before you come in. That’s our job. We identify and appraise everything for free and explain what drives the value of each piece.
What is the best way to sell an inherited coin collection?
Bring the whole collection in as-is, without sorting or cleaning. We catalog everything, identify the pieces that carry real numismatic value versus bullion or face value, and give you an itemized written offer. Inherited estates are a large part of what we handle.
Do NYC coin buyers pay cash?
Yes. When you accept an offer, you can leave with cash up to our daily limit, or we can wire the funds to your bank the same business day for larger purchases.
How much are pre-1964 silver coins worth today?
Pre-1964 U.S. dimes, quarters, and half dollars are 90% silver, so their base value tracks the live silver spot price and the coin’s silver weight. Call for today’s number. Offers are quoted against the current market, not a fixed price.
Do you buy gold American Eagles in New York?
Yes. We buy American Gold Eagles and Buffalos, Krugerrands, Maple Leafs, and other government-minted gold, paid on weight and purity against the live gold market plus any premium.
Do you make house calls for large collections?
For large collections or situations where transport is difficult, ask about an at-home appraisal anywhere in the five boroughs. Our buyers can come to you when the collection warrants it. Call 347-650-4078 to discuss.
Ready when you are
Call NYC Coin Buyers Today
Monday – Saturday · 10am – 6pm
347-650-4078Appointment preferred · Written offers · Cash or wire same day
Request a quote
Get in touch
Tell us about your collection and a buyer will call you back the same day.