Sell Coins (We Buy Gold, Silver & Rare Coins)
Sell Coins in NYC – NYC Coin Buyers
If you’re searching for the most trusted place to sell coins in NYC, NYC Coin Buyers is your best choice. We specialize in buying gold, silver, and rare coins of all kinds — from individual pieces to complete collections. Located in the heart of New York City, we’ve earned a strong reputation for transparency, fair market appraisals, and fast payment.
Our professional numismatists (coin experts) have decades of experience evaluating U.S. and international coins. Whether you inherited a coin collection or want to liquidate an investment, we make the process smooth and simple. You’ll receive a free, no-obligation valuation and an instant offer based on real-time market data.
Here is why so many New Yorkers choose to work with us: our process is honest, efficient, and fully focused on your best outcome. We buy coins directly — no middlemen — so you receive more money for your collection.
Why Sell Your Coins to Us?
Selling coins can feel confusing, especially with so many online buyers and pawn shops claiming to offer the best prices. At NYC Coin Buyers, we make it straightforward. Here’s how we stand out:
1. Transparent Appraisals
We believe in open communication. Every coin is evaluated right in front of you. You’ll learn how we determine value based on metal content, rarity, demand, and historical significance. No hidden fees, no vague estimates — just real numbers you can trust.
2. Top Market Value Offers
We stay updated on global bullion prices, collector trends, and auction records. This means our offers reflect current market conditions, not outdated charts. Whether you’re selling a 1907 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle or modern American Silver Eagles, you’ll receive top dollar.
3. Expertise You Can Rely On
Our team includes lifelong collectors and professional coin graders. We recognize subtle details that most buyers overlook — such as mint errors, strike quality, or rare varieties. This expertise ensures that rare coins are priced correctly, not melted for metal value.
4. Fast and Private Transactions
We value your time and privacy. Appraisals usually take less than 15 minutes. Once you accept our offer, you get paid immediately by cash, check, or bank transfer. No waiting periods or mailing delays.
5. Local NYC Trust
We’ve served clients from Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx for years. Many of our customers return to us again and again because they know we stand behind our word. From Wall Street investors to family estates, we’ve handled it all.
What Types of Coins Do We Buy?
Our buying services cover virtually every type of coin — from common circulation pieces to world-class rarities. Let’s break down the main categories we handle every day.
Gold Coins
Gold coins are among the most sought-after items we buy. We evaluate each coin by both its gold content and collector value. Some of the most popular gold coins we purchase include:
American Gold Eagles and Buffalos
Canadian Maple Leafs
South African Krugerrands
British Sovereigns
Pre-1933 U.S. Gold Coins (Liberty and Saint-Gaudens series)
Foreign Gold Coins from France, Switzerland, and Austria
Whether you have one coin or a full tube, our appraisers will weigh, test, and price your gold with precision.
Silver Coins
Silver coins are another strong area of interest for collectors and investors. We buy everything from junk silver to high-grade proof coins. These include:
American Silver Eagles
Morgan and Peace Dollars
90% Silver Dimes, Quarters, and Halves
Commemorative Silver Issues
Foreign Silver Coins from Canada, Mexico, and Europe
Even heavily circulated silver coins can carry value, especially when silver prices are high. Bring in your rolls or bags, and we’ll count and value them on the spot.
Rare and Collectible Coins
Numismatic coins — those valued for rarity or historical importance — are where our expertise shines. We pay a premium for coins with low mintages, rare dates, or unique errors. Examples include:
Key-date Lincoln Cents (1909-S VDB, 1914-D)
Rare Buffalo Nickels and Standing Liberty Quarters
Early U.S. Type Coins from the 18th and 19th centuries
Mint-state and proof coins graded by PCGS or NGC
Coins with interesting stories or provenance
We handle single rarities and full collections alike. Many clients come to us after discovering old albums or inherited estates that may contain hidden treasures.
Bullion and Investment Coins
If you purchased precious metals for investment, we’ll buy your bullion coins and bars at competitive market rates. Our team tracks live spot prices to ensure your payout matches the metal’s current value. Accepted items include:
U.S. Mint and Royal Canadian Mint bullion coins
Silver, gold, and platinum bars
1 oz, 10 oz, and 1 kilo bullion rounds
Mixed lots of bullion coins
World Coins
We also purchase coins from around the world. Many older European and Asian coins carry strong collector demand. Whether you have ancient Roman coins or 20th-century European silver crowns, we’ll identify and price them accurately.
Factors That Determine the Value of Your Coins
Coin values depend on multiple factors, not just metal weight. Let’s go through the main elements we evaluate during every appraisal.
1. Metal Content
Gold, silver, platinum, and palladium coins hold intrinsic value based on their precious metal content. This provides a baseline worth even for common coins. We measure purity and weight to calculate metal value using current market spot prices.
2. Rarity and Mintage
The fewer coins produced or surviving today, the higher the demand. A coin minted in limited quantities or one with a unique variety (such as a doubled die or overdate) can command high premiums.
3. Condition (Grade)
Coin grading has a major impact on value. We follow the Sheldon Scale, which ranges from Poor (P-1) to Perfect Mint State (MS-70). Even a one-point difference can mean hundreds or thousands of dollars.
4. Demand Among Collectors
Some coins remain popular regardless of mintage due to strong collector interest. For example, Morgan Dollars and Lincoln Cents are always in demand because they appeal to both casual and serious collectors.
5. Market Conditions
Like any investment, the coin market fluctuates. Gold and silver spot prices, economic uncertainty, and collector trends all influence value. We monitor these variables daily to give you fair, up-to-date offers.
6. Historical Significance
Coins with ties to major events or figures — such as Civil War-era coins or early colonial pieces — carry added historical and cultural value.
7. Authenticity and Certification
Coins authenticated and graded by respected third-party services such as PCGS or NGC usually sell for more. We verify each coin’s legitimacy through specialized testing and visual inspection.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know my coins are valuable?
You don’t need to guess — bring them in for a free evaluation. We’ll identify each coin and explain what makes it valuable, such as rarity, metal content, or condition. Even everyday coins can be worth more than you expect, especially older U.S. silver issues or unique mint errors.
Do I need to clean my coins before bringing them in?
No. Cleaning coins can reduce their value by removing natural patina or causing micro-scratches. We recommend leaving them in their original condition. Our experts can assess them safely as-is.
How long does the appraisal take?
Most appraisals take between 10 and 20 minutes, depending on collection size. We value each coin carefully and give you an immediate offer. You can choose to sell on the spot or take your time to decide.
What payment methods do you offer?
We pay immediately after you accept the offer. You can choose cash, check, or bank transfer. For large transactions, we can also arrange same-day wire transfers for your convenience.
Can I sell coins on behalf of an estate or family member?
Absolutely. We frequently assist clients managing estates or inheritances. We’ll help organize, appraise, and purchase coins directly from the estate, ensuring a fair and transparent process. If needed, we can also provide a written appraisal for legal or insurance purposes.
Contact Us Today!
Ready to discover what your coins are really worth? Visit NYC Coin Buyers, the trusted name in New York for coin appraisals and purchases.
What We Buy: Gold coins, silver coins, rare coins, bullion, and entire collections
Contact: Call or visit for a free, no-obligation appraisal
Walk in with your coins, walk out with confidence — and cash in hand.